http://www.moniteausaddleclub.com/flyspray_recipes.htmWe've used a recipe from here sucessfully for a couple of summers-well it feels like longer as midges seem to be around for ever-
combined with stop itch and avoiding peak midge times in the field.
I have not managed to copy it but it's at the bottom with cider vinegar, skin so soft and citronnella. At least buying citronella is not embarassing!
I think different things suit different horses just like some stuff suits some people and not others. Good luck.